We’re squarely in mid-October now, and the leaves have started changing and falling. Here in the Niagara region, except for one storm, we’ve had some really sunny dry weather, with temperatures in the mid to low teens.
If you haven’t already fone so, it’s a good time to start thinking about leaf cleanup.
Trees lose their leaves at different times in the fall. Some trees are more sensitive to cold, or let go of their foliage sooner, and that’s not necessarily just by species. It can also depend on where a tree is located on a property.
There’s a garden I take care of that has two tulip trees. One is in the front garden and one is in the back. The front one is a little bit more exposed, and tends to lose its foliage first. The one in the back holds on to its leaves for maybe another week or two.
So even within one garden, leaf cleanup doesn’t necessarily happen all at once.
A Little at a Time
Because I take care of gardens on a weekly or biweekly basis, I’m often able to do a little bit of leaf cleanup every week. That way, there isn’t one enormous batch to do at the end of the season. It’s just an ongoing process.
If you have a lawn, for example, and you have some time on the weekends, you can rake up the leaves every week. That allows your lawn to get a little more sunlight later into the season, rather than sitting under a thick layer of fallen foliage.
It also changes the look of the garden.
If you’re doing ongoing cleanup, you’re maintaining something closer to your summer garden look. It creates a more static image of your garden, almost extending summer for a little longer. There’s not as much visible death, foliage drop, and accumulation.
If you enjoy having a manicured green lawn, then regular leaf cleanup is one way to maintain that visual effect for a little longer.
But there are other advantages.
One of the biggest, for me, is that it staggers the workload.
Let’s say leaf cleanup puts some stress on your shoulders, or lower back. If you’re doing one enormous cleanup, you’re concentrating all that physical effort into one or two days. But if you spread the work over a longer period, you’re doing less at a time.
Not only does that put less stress on your body during each session, it also gives your body an opportunity to adapt to the work.
It’s a little bit like working out.
This summer I did some swimming, and I found that doing it for a few days, taking a few days off, and then returning allowed my body to recover in between. The muscle groups being engaged had time to build up.
Leaf cleanup can work in a similar way. You’re repeating the activity, with recovery time in between, rather than asking your body to do everything in one enormous effort.
For me, that’s a more sustainable approach, and a form of injury prevention.
The other advantage is that, because you’re already in the garden, you can do other things while you’re there.
For example, I often stagger my fall cutbacks along with my leaf cleanup.
For example, certain varieties of hostas are already looking a little scorched, bleached, slug-eaten or frostbitten. Some peonies are more prone to mildew, and are completely white and fuzzy by now. I can remove those first and leave the remaining plants that still have some structure or visual interest.
As the season progresses, I can return and do a little more.
We’ve discussed this approach in more detail in my previous post about fall cutbacks.
Rather than doing everything in one visit, you’re distributing the maintenance throughout the season. And because there’s less leaf cleanup to do each time, you also have an opportunity to fine-tune the garden.
All at Once
Of course, not everybody has the time or the opportunity to visit their garden every week.
Sometimes it’s simply more practical to let the leaves fall and then dedicate one weekend to cleaning everything up.
This can be especially true for a property you don’t visit regularly, or a garden in a remote location. If you’re not on site, you can’t get to the leaves.
It also depends on how many leaves you’re dealing with.
If you have a small tree that drops only a relatively small amount of foliage, there may be very little reason to keep going out and raking every weekend. You might as well wait until the leaves have fallen and do it all at once.
And if you have the strength and endurance for one large cleanup, and that works better with your schedule, then it may be a perfectly reasonable approach.
Some trees are planted specifically for their fall leaf skirt. Ginkgos, for example, have beautifully uniform deep yellow fall leaves. They also tend to fall all at once. This can create a stunning effect in your garden: A bare ginkgo with a perfect yellow circle below. Some consider this a worthwile design effect. Even if fleeting, it can be enjoyed for a week or two before raking.
There’s also something to be said for leaf cleanup as a fall ritual.
I have memories of playing in piles of leaves when I was younger.
There’s the smell of the leaves, that slight decomposition, the remnants of a rainfall followed by a dry fall day. The crunch of the leaves as you gather them into an enormous pile.
And if you’re very small, you can hide in that pile of leaves.
So there’s a different experience to gathering everything at once, especially if you have children who enjoy playing in the leaves.
Ultimately, how you distribute the work is going to depend on your property, your schedule, your physical capacity, and what you enjoy doing.
Different Areas of the Garden
One thing worth considering is that you don’t necessarily have to apply the same leaf cleanup strategy to every part of your garden.
There are lawns, there are planting beds, and there are hard surfaces, like walkways, driveways, and parking spaces.
Each has different needs.
For example, there’s a garden I take care of where we blow off the pathways amd rake the lawn every week, but leave the leaves in the planting beds until later in the season.
Eventually, we’ll skim some of the excess leaves off the surface of the beds, but we don’t remove everything. We leave a layer behind to feed the garden, and for insects and other small creatures that use leaf litter for shelter.
The lawn, however, stays clear.
You can also prioritize different parts of the property.
Let’s say you have a front garden where leaves tend to accumulate, and the next big gust of wind is likely to scatter them across the street or into your neighbors’ gardens.
Keeping that area tidy on a regular basis can help manage where those leaves end up.
Meanwhile, you might decide to leave the back garden until later in the season, when you’re ready for one larger cleanup.
It’s a selective approach. You’re focusing your energy on the areas where it matters most. Making those simple decisions can reduce your to-do list and associated mental stress as well.
Working With the Weather
Weather makes a huge difference when it comes to leaf cleanup.
Because I take care of several gardens, I have some flexibility in my schedule, but it’s limited. Sometimes I end up cleaning leaves on a wet, darker day simply because that’s when I’m there.
But if you have the option, I would recommend choosing a dry day.
Dry leaves are much lighter and generally easier to manage.
Wet leaves become surprisingly heavy, especially once you’ve gathered them into yard-waste bags. The weight is a significant consideration if you’re going to be lifting and moving those bags.
Paper yard-waste bags are generally made to be fairly resilient, but filling them with soaked leaves and then leaving them outside for a week before collection can put that resilience to the test.
Dry leaves also respond much better to a blower. Wet leaves tend to stick to the ground, and to each other, making them more difficult to move.
Then there’s the gardener.
If you’re cleaning up leaves in wet conditions, your gloves get wet, your clothes get wet, your shoes and socks get wet.
Clothing becomes a much greater consideration.
Having done plenty of leaf cleanup in wet conditions, I highly value wool socks, a wool base layer, a waterproof jacket, and sometimes even waterproof pants. A good pair of waterproof sneakers or boots goes a long way to ensure your comfort, and therefore endurance.
You can certainly clean up leaves in wet weather, but having the right clothing makes the experience much more manageable.
Working With Wind
Wind can be just as significant as rain.
If you’re working in a very open location, the wind can pick up the leaves you’ve just gathered and scatter them around again.
Whether you’re using a rake or a blower, it’s generally much easier to work in the direction of the wind rather than against it.
Otherwise, you’re fighting a losing battle.
If you need to move leaves against the wind, try approaching the direction diagonally rather than going straight into it. It’s a little bit like trying to reach the opposite bank of a river by working at an angle.
And remember that wind doesn’t stop at your property line. It’s another reason why regular cleanup can be useful in front gardens or areas close to neighbors.
Tools for Leaf Cleanup
There are a few tools that I find particularly useful for leaf cleanup, and which ones you choose will depend on your garden.
Rakes
First, you’ll need a rake, or possibly a few different rakes.
Different styles of rakes do slightly different things. I’ve discussed them in more detail in my earlier post about garden rakes.
For leaf cleanup, I usually use two metal rakes: a wider one and a narrower one.
The wider rake is essential for covering large lawn areas, while the narrower one is much easier to maneuver through smaller planting beds and tight spaces.
There are also plastic rakes and extendable rakes.
I don’t tend to use my extendable rake very often anymore because its round tines don’t grab the leaves quite the same way. But it still works, and it can be particularly useful in small areas.
Blowers
I know people have mixed opinions about leaf blowers, but I find them essential for certain tasks.
Battery-operated blowers, in particular, make life much easier.
They’re especially useful for hard surfaces like walkways, driveways, and parking spaces. Even if all you’re doing is blowing leaves off a walkway and onto the lawn, that can make a significant difference in how tidy the garden feels.
I don’t use a blower exclusively, especially in planting beds.
A blower can be a little overpowering and may blow away your mulch along with the leaves. If you have a variable-speed blower and can gently skim the surface, that’s helpful, but otherwise I generally recommend using both a rake and a blower.
For a manicured lawn, I’ll sometimes rake up most of the leaves first, then make a second pass with the blower.
Some trees, like locust trees, have very fine leaves that are difficult to collect with a rake. A blower can gather those remaining leaves into a pile where they’re much easier to pick up.
There’s quite a bit more to discuss about how to use a blower effectively, so I’ll save that for a separate post.
Moving and Collecting Leaves
Once you’ve gathered the leaves, you need somewhere to put them.
If you have a larger property and somewhere to pile leaves for decomposition, you might use a large tarp, a wheelbarrow, or a combination of the two to transport them.
I’ve also seen people use the enormous reusable bags that are sometimes used for soil deliveries. They’re a great size for leaves, and you can put one on a wheelbarrow and move quite a large quantity at once.
For most of the gardens I take care of, however, I use paper yard-waste bags.
And if you’re using yard-waste bags, I find a leaf chute to be a game changer.
A leaf chute holds the bag open and helps it keep its structure, making it much easier to fill.
It also gives you a little bit of space to put your foot inside the bag and really press down on the leaves, compacting them so you can fit more into each bag.
Without a leaf chute, yard-waste bags can be frustrating to hold open while you’re trying to fill them.
For me, a leaf chute is an underrated essential part of leaf cleanup.
What Happens to the Leaves?
Leaf cleanup doesn’t necessarily mean removing all the leaves from your property.
There are several ways to make use of them.
One option is to run your lawn mower over the leaves, chopping them into much smaller pieces.
These shredded leaves can decompose more readily and return organic material and nutrients to your lawn. You can also collect them and spread them into planting beds, where they’ll gradually break down.
It’s essentially a form of composting on site.
You can also add leaves to your own compost pile.
Good compost generally needs a balance of carbon-rich materials, often called browns, and nitrogen-rich materials, or greens.
Fallen leaves are an excellent source of carbon.
You don’t necessarily have to shred them before composting, although smaller pieces will generally break down more quickly.
One consideration, however, is disease.
If you’re dealing with foliage that has been affected by a fungal disease, I generally recommend keeping that material out of your home compost.
Unless you’re maintaining a composting system that reliably reaches temperatures sufficient to kill the relevant pathogens, you may end up reintroducing diseased material into your garden.
It’s possible to achieve high composting temperatures at home, but it takes some diligence.
For that reason, I prefer to dispose of heavily diseased foliage through an appropriate municipal collection system rather than returning it to the garden.
Municipal Leaf Collection
It’s worth checking how your municipality handles leaf collection, because different cities and towns have different systems.
Some offer regular yard-waste bag collection, so you can fill your bags and leave them at the curb on the appropriate collection day.
Other municipalities have special fall leaf collection programs.
Burlington, Ontario, for example, has used a system where homeowners in designated areas can place loose leaves at the roadside for collection by specialized equipment, according to a schedule.
There are advantages and disadvantages to these systems, including the possibility of wind scattering leaves before they’re collected.
But the important thing is to know your municipality’s schedule.
If your area only receives leaf collection during one or two designated periods, that may determine when you need to have your garden cleaned up.
Finding Your Own Approach
Leaf cleanup doesn’t have to happen all at once, and it doesn’t have to happen the same way throughout your property.
You might clear your lawn every weekend, leave the leaves in your planting beds, keep your walkways tidy with a blower, and wait until later in the season to tackle the back garden.
Or you might prefer to let everything fall and dedicate one weekend to gathering it all up.
You might mulch some leaves into your lawn, move others into planting beds, add some to your compost, and bag the remainder for collection.
The important thing is to look at what’s happening in your own garden.
How many leaves are falling? Where are they accumulating? What needs to stay clear? What can be left alone? How much work can you comfortably do?
And perhaps most importantly, what do you actually want your garden to look and feel like during the fall?
For me, regular leaf cleanup is part of the rhythm of maintaining gardens throughout the season. It allows me to distribute the work, return regularly, and make small adjustments as the garden changes.
But there isn’t one approach that needs to apply to every garden.
Sometimes cleanup means removing leaves. Sometimes it simply means moving them somewhere more useful.
And sometimes, it means leaving them exactly where they are.