As a gardener, sometimes I witness the removal of large trees from a property. Often, it’s not even a property that I garden for.
However, these tree removals have an effect on the wider area, because trees are large. People notice them being gone, or being altered in some way.
There is also a general understanding that removing trees is bad. In cities, there has been a movement toward making tree removal more difficult, because trees, it turns out, are essential for many ecological services that cities need.
In larger metropolitan areas such as Hamilton or Toronto, for example, trees help combat the heat island effect. They provide shade, support biodiversity, provide habitat for wildlife, and generally make cities more pleasant places to live.
Planting trees, and planting appropriate species, can help mitigate some of the environmental problems that cities face.
However, sometimes removing trees is necessary.
Trees become diseased, hollow, or structurally unsound. Sometimes they were planted in the wrong place. Sometimes they have grown too large for the space available, or they interfere with buildings and other structures.
And sometimes people buy a property and remove old trees because they’re in the way, or because they simply don’t like the design.
There are many reasons why people remove trees.
And there are many opinions about which of those reasons are good ones.
I’m not particularly interested in attacking anybody for removing a tree. I have both removed trees and planted them. Every garden ownership has its own subtleties, and as an observer I’m not in a position to judge.
I’m more interested in the questions that tree removal brings up.
Who Owns a Tree?
Who owns trees? What does tree ownership mean?
What’s strange to me is that trees have very long lifespans.
A tree could be on a property for forty years, fifty years, two hundred years, or longer.
Human lives are often shorter than tree lives. Not only that, but human land possession, even though we’re talking about possession, is actually very fleeting compared to the lifespan of a tree.
People move houses within decades, sometimes years. Human lives generally span less than a century.
But trees can remain in the same place through several generations of people.
A tree may be planted by one person, maintained by another, and eventually removed by somebody who had nothing to do with its planting.
Trees get transferred from owner to owner.
And so what does it mean to own a tree?
Beyond their duration, trees are also so large that they significantly influence the streetscape and cityscape.
Even though they grow on what we call private property, whatever that means, they’re also in the public eye.
A large tree may shade a neighboring garden. Its canopy may extend over the street. It may provide habitat for wildlife that moves between properties. It may become part of the familiar appearance of an entire neighborhood.
The Sycamore Gap tree in the UK is a particularly public example, but every community has their own loved trees.
In a way, these trees belong to the public’s experience, even though they don’t belong to the public legally.
They are privately owned, but publicly experienced.
And so one of the questions becomes: who are we to kill trees?
Buying Time
Trees are planted for many different reasons.
Sometimes somebody has a seedling that was given to them for free and simply needs somewhere to put it.
Sometimes a tree wasn’t planted at all. It seeded itself in the garden, and nobody noticed it when it was small enough to weed.
Manitoba maples, for example, can grow quickly in places where nobody intended to have a tree. By the time they become large and intrusive, perhaps growing against a building or interfering with a foundation, removing them becomes a much larger project.
Sometimes trees were deliberately planted because they were considered desirable at the time.
Norway maples, for example, were once widely prized as ornamental and shade trees. Now they are recognized as invasive in parts of North America.
Times change, and our understanding changes with them.
Someone may have invested twenty, thirty, or forty years into growing a tree that, according to our current understanding, wasn’t the right tree to invest in in the first place.
Although right is a relative term here.
The person who planted it may have been working with the best information available to them.
And that brings up another difficulty. We are making decisions on very large time scales, often with incomplete information.
There isn’t always a great deal of plant literacy. People may not know which trees are native or non-native, which are invasive, which are valuable to wildlife, or how a particular species will behave over time.
Sometimes people remove trees lightly, without understanding what they’re removing.
Other times, people feel guilty about removing a tree that really is the wrong tree in the wrong spot.
There is a tension between treating trees as though they should never be removed, and treating them as though they can simply be replaced.
Because they can’t always be replaced.
When you buy a property with an old tree already growing on it, in a way, you’re buying time.
If a tree is already tall enough to provide privacy, screen a neighboring property, or shade your garden, you don’t have to wait twenty or thirty years for those benefits to develop.
They’re already there.
And this isn’t something that money can necessarily buy.
Even with unlimited money and resources, there is a limit to the size of tree that can be purchased and successfully transplanted.
Young trees are relatively adaptable to new conditions. Larger, older trees are more difficult to move, and the risks increase with their size.
You might be able to move a twenty-year-old Japanese maple.
But you can’t realistically move a two-hundred-and-fifty-year-old silver maple.
So if you have one already growing on your property, you have something that cannot simply be replaced by purchasing another tree.
And this isn’t just sentimental.
If you remove a five-year-old tree, you can probably replace it with another young tree, and within a few years have something similar.
But if you remove a two-hundred-and-fifty-year-old silver maple, the finality of that decision is very different.
The increased age increases the complexity of the existing resource.
And so there is a need to understand the situation more deeply before making that decision.
The Invention of Trees
I like old trees.
Partly because of the time embedded in them.
A seedling has a lot of potential. But a two-hundred-and-fifty-year-old silver maple has accumulated something that a seedling simply hasn’t had the time to accumulate.
Consider the sound of the leaves of a five-year-old silver maple, compared with a two-hundred-and-fifty-year-old silver maple, when the wind rustles through them.
It’s very different.
There’s such an increased complexity in the foliage of the large tree. All those layers of leaves and branches moving in the wind. The sound of the entire canopy.
There’s quite something about it.
And then, if we go further back in time, there was a point when trees didn’t exist at all.
Trees had to be invented.
Or rather, at some point in Earth’s history, trees invented themselves.
Through evolution, plants developed the structures that allowed them to grow taller, support large woody trunks, and form forests.
And the advent of trees significantly changed Earth.
They changed soils, water cycles, atmospheric conditions, and the habitats available to other living things.
Trees didn’t simply appear within an existing world. Their evolution helped change the conditions of that world.
So when we talk about trees, we’re talking about organisms that have been shaping their surroundings for an extraordinarily long time.
And individual trees continue doing that.
A large tree isn’t just a trunk with some leaves attached. It has created conditions around itself. Shade, moisture, shelter, habitat, relationships with other plants and animals.
Over decades and centuries, those relationships become increasingly complex.
When a large tree is removed, we aren’t necessarily removing only the tree.
We’re also changing the conditions that the tree created.
What Is a Tree Worth?
We can put a monetary value on a tree.
There are ways to calculate the financial value of mature trees, their contribution to property values, and the ecological services they provide.
But money is a human-made language. A way of communicating value.
A tree exists outside of money, and its value exists outside of money.
For example, being able to garden in a shaded garden on the hottest summer day makes an enormous difference to me.
That shade makes my work more comfortable. It provides relief from the heat.
How much is that worth?
Or the sound of the leaves of an old silver maple when the wind moves through them?
Or the presence of a tree that has been growing in the same place for centuries?
Some trees are particularly valuable because they have become rare.
Black birch, also called cherry birch, is native to this region but uncommon. American chestnut was once an important part of eastern North American forests, before chestnut blight devastated its populations.
Having one of these trees growing on a property is different from having a commonly planted ornamental tree.
But even then, what makes one tree more valuable than another?
Its rarity? Its size? Its age? Its beauty? The wildlife it supports? The services it provides?
And value can change depending on what we’re comparing.
A large tree may provide tremendous ecological benefits. But so can a meadow, or a wetland.
In some circumstances, meadows and wetlands can provide greater ecological value than forests, depending on what we’re measuring and what ecosystem we’re considering.
Removing a tree that supports relatively little native wildlife, and replacing it with a diverse native meadow, may improve the ecological function of a particular site.
So planting trees isn’t automatically the best ecological decision in every situation.
And removing a tree isn’t automatically the worst.
Which brings us back to the question of understanding what we’re working with.
There Are Many Ways to Kill a Tree
There are many ways to kill a tree.
One is to cut it down.
Another is to introduce something into its environment that kills it.
The American chestnut is an extraordinary example.
Chestnut blight arrived in North America through imported Asian chestnut material. The disease spread through eastern forests and, within decades, devastated billions of American chestnut trees.
The consequences of that introduction are still with us.
One introduction, followed by a chain of events that extended far beyond the original action.
And often, we don’t know the consequences of these things until it’s too late.
There’s something strange here.
You can introduce life that kills, and you can kill things that allow life.
A tree can be planted with the intention of improving a property, and eventually become an ecological problem.
Another tree can be removed with very little thought, even though it has been supporting an enormous amount of life.
If you cut down a whole bunch of trees, the wildlife living in them doesn’t simply disappear.
Some of it moves into neighboring gardens and neighboring trees. Some finds new habitat. Some may not survive the loss.
The consequences extend beyond the boundaries of the property where the trees were removed.
And sometimes those consequences take years, or decades, to become apparent.
This is part of what makes tree removal difficult to evaluate.
We don’t always understand the value of a tree, or its presence in the ecosystem.
And we don’t always know what we’re changing.
Trees, Lumber, and Human Life
There’s also another side to the relationship between humans and trees.
Trees are a harvestable resource.
Particularly in Canada, where our building industry has been based on lumber for centuries.
Our history, our culture, and the way we build our homes are deeply connected to harvesting trees.
It’s not as easy as simply deciding to stop using lumber. The industry has developed over centuries, and it’s embedded in the way our society functions.
There are also different ways of harvesting trees, from clear-cutting to selective harvesting and individual thinning.
And different ways of managing forests over time.
We coexist with dead trees all the time.
We build our houses from them. We make furniture, floors, shelves, and countless other objects from wood.
We even spend time selecting which kind of wood we want for a charcuterie board.
Different woods have different characteristics, different appearances, and different values.
So tree death is already part of human culture.
And yet, when a large tree is removed from a familiar streetscape, people can have a very strong emotional reaction.
Which makes sense.
That tree may have been part of their everyday experience for decades. They may have walked beneath it, watched its leaves change color, or simply known it as part of the place where they live.
We can accept the harvesting of trees as part of human life, while also recognizing that the removal of a particular tree can be a significant loss.
I also think there’s something interesting about the way we distinguish human life from tree life.
They’re both life.
Of course, humans and trees are very different organisms, and we have very different relationships with them. I would be comfortable cutting down a tree under the right circumstances. I would not be comfortable doing the same to a human.
But both are living things, existing within larger systems of life.
And the fact that we are able to remove a tree doesn’t necessarily mean that we understand everything we’re removing.
Things Larger Than Us
So what can we do within the systems we’ve created?
You can’t necessarily control what your neighbor cuts down.
Some municipalities have regulations protecting trees, while others have very few restrictions on tree removal.
And you can’t individually control the entire social or legal structure within which you live.
But you can make decisions about the trees on your own property.
You can remove what you see fit to remove. You can replace it with something you consider a better choice. Or you can preserve what is already there.
And deeper ecological knowledge, a better understanding of what you’re working with, can lead to better decisions, whether that means removing a tree or keeping it.
This isn’t limited to individuals.
Towns, cities, and countries can also make decisions about the landscapes they maintain.
People can come together and create systems that preserve things that far exceed individual human lifespans.
And I think this is interesting because humans live relatively short lives, but we are capable of creating things that last much longer than we do.
Buildings can be larger than us. Cities and towns can be larger than us.
Books can be passed down through generations.
Language is larger than us.
The Earth is larger than us. The solar system is larger than us. Humans are even getting to the point where we can consider redirecting asteroids, potentially preventing extinction-level events.
So we’re always tinkering with things larger than ourselves.
And we can create systems that are sometimes fleeting, sometimes enduring, that allow things to continue existing beyond our individual lives.
An old-growth forest is something that has developed over a time span far longer than a human lifetime.
A century-old tree is something that no single person can create within a season.
There is something here that money can’t buy.
Only time, and particular decisions made over time, can produce it.
Sometimes those decisions span multiple human lives.
One person plants a tree. Another maintains it. Someone else chooses to preserve it. And generations later, people who had nothing to do with its planting get to experience what has accumulated.
It’s a collaborative effort.
And that brings us back to ownership.
We may own a property for a few years, or a few decades. We may have the authority to decide what happens to the trees growing there.
But the trees themselves can be part of something that extends far beyond our own lives, and beyond the boundaries of the land we own.
We can’t redirect asteroids individually.
But we can make decisions about the trees on our own property.